Contact Us
Fill out the form below to contact us with any questions, comments, or concerns.
What People Are Saying
we've been looking for good NY style pizza since we moved here from the Philly area. we tried pies & pints and bazbeaux, and they're good if you want an...
-Linda J., 11/26/2022Source:
Great place, especially for getting pizza by the slice. The pizza is really good, and staff have always been very friendly. This is one of my favorite lunch spots.
-Rob Tuckfield, 11/17/2022Source:
The ice cream and staff are great! Their recommendations on flavor combinations are always delicious.
-Michael Q., 10/05/2022Source:
Best pizza in indiana hands down!
-Richard Stewart, 09/30/2022Source:
Delicious pepperoni breadsticks. The crust is perfectly thin, and “floppy” in the best way. Delicious!
-Cameron Workman-Moore, 09/29/2022Source:
Hands down the best New style pizza around.
-Dodd Berry, 09/22/2022Source:
I grew up in NY, this is the closest I've found to being as good as NY pizza in Carmel.
-elisa Savinelli, 09/18/2022Source:
The hands down best pizza by the slice on the north side of Indianapolis
-Doug Mallio, 09/06/2022Source:
Amazing food. I just wish they were open late!!
-Jon Hughs, 08/29/2022Source:
Great pizza place
-Maria Fernanda Aguirre, 08/16/2022Source:
Always delicious and always great customer service.
-Tianna Penn, 08/12/2022Source:
Great quick meal at reasonable prices
-John E Ridder (Labyrinthguy), 08/10/2022Source:
One of the best pizza places in Noblesville!
-Devin Whitley, 07/29/2022Source:
Closest thing to NY pizza, love it, don't change a thing. Maybe slightly thinner crust as an option.
-Bhupinder Calotia, 07/23/2022Source:
I like it, not the best but definitely is good
-Scott McCord, 07/16/2022Source:
Good Pizza, Good Breadsticks, only been here 2 times so far, and both times were great! Customer service was good, welcomed me in and thanked me for visiting! I'll be back more often!
-Jeffery Biedermann, 07/08/2022Source:
Good
-Jose Perera Nieles, 07/04/2022Source:
Always lightning fast and good variety on the toppings. Try the supreme, it's fantastic
-Flyingferrets5, 07/02/2022Source:
Has the best pizza master making their original NYC STYLE PIZZA LOVE IT
-Daniel “GONORRHEA” Giraldo, 06/03/2022Source:
They have great pizza, friendly employees, and good service.
-Elevator Dude, 05/01/2022Source:
Authentic pizza being made
-Ricky Bullock, 04/30/2022Source:
Love it
-Paula Jo Golday, 04/11/2022Source:
Always amazing
-Nakuma Stone, 04/10/2022Source:
Delicious fresh pizza and kind staff
-Kevin Quay, 03/13/2022Source:
Love Bella pizza. Best NY style pizza around, only if you get it fresh, reheated slices are ok.
-Mojo, 03/12/2022Source:
Not to shabby
-Justin Collado, 02/03/2022Source:
Tasty pizza.
-Greg Hess, 01/21/2022Source:
Very good pizza & breadsticks.
-Joo-Yun Kim, 12/11/2021Source:
They have an amazingly friendly staff. The team was more than patient with me picking up my Door Dash order a few minutes after they were close. Great team and great food!
-Constance Bates-Bingham, 12/07/2021Source:
All I can say is wow 🤩 great New York style pizza
-Jason Bryant, 12/06/2021Source:
I had not been to Bella pizza since they closed their location by Keystone. I was passing by Clay Terrace and decided to pick up a takeout order for a tasty...
-Carmen W., 12/03/2021Source:
My go to place for NY style pizza. Close as I can get to foldable slices of my youth!
-Douglas McLean, 11/08/2021Source:
Best Cannolis!!! Great pizza,and breadsticks. Service is excellent.
-Sharon Mason, 10/21/2021Source:
Just moved to fishers and this is hands down the best NY style pizza I’ve had! Great for Sunday football
-Jesse Hall, 09/13/2021Source:
Always yummy.... Just wish one was a little closer to home!
-amy hoopingarner, 09/01/2021Source:
YUM. Just a great place to run and grab a slice! Really friendly crew. :)
-Wendy Cox, 08/22/2021Source:
Their pepperoni bread stick are outstanding. I live in Avon and when I am on the north side it’s a must to stop by Bella’s at the west clay Simon mall to get 3 orders to take home
-Tim Toler (Lotman), 08/10/2021Source:
This is amazing pizza! It's just like I grew up with and definitely brought back memories. The white pizza is divine! Love, love, love!
-Amber Brocken, 08/05/2021Source:
Great food ....love there pizza ate it when I was pregnant an I couldn't get enough. My man works here an I love it 😊. Very nice place to eat pizza an family friendly
-Anjela Sizemore, 02/13/2021Source:
Email Signup
Join our email list today to receive exclusive special offers!