Fantastic service and even better pizza

-Taylor Hansen,   10/21/2018Source:

Love the pizza I am from NJ and its hard to satisfy a Jersey girl of good pizza but this pizza is definitely like NJ pizza!! Just an FYI I cant get you new website to work so I cant order online :(

10/21/2018Source:

Perhaps the only thing I miss about living in Charlotte, NC was the influx of New Yorkers that had opened up pizza joints around town. If you understand...

-Justin A.,   10/02/2018Source:

Seriously the best pizza in Indy!! They have great deals all the time, quick delivery service and friendly staff!

-Chrissy W.,   10/01/2018Source:

Yum!!!

-Aaron Wilson,   09/29/2018Source:

Extremely fast delivery and the guy was funny. Wasn't the best pizza in the world but the star service.

-Kayla Parks,   09/26/2018Source:

Stopped here for lunch. Great atmosphere, fast service, delicious food. Definitely recommended.

-Kaleb Davis,   09/25/2018Source:

I love their pizza

-Sarah Norman,   09/25/2018Source:

Only truely New York style pizza in town.

-c g,   09/12/2018Source:

Good pizza and friendly service. Free Wifi was hidden surprise that let me do some work during a quick lunch.

-aaron hockel,   09/06/2018Source:

Best damn pizza around My son and I have a code word we use around other family members when we want to sneak out for some father / son time

09/04/2018Source:

Me gusto

-Kgris Gamboa,   09/03/2018Source:

NY style pizza in Indiana? Why did it take us so long to find this place?!!? Nothing beats being able to walk up and say, "I want THAT slice", and getting...

-Kassie J.,   08/27/2018Source:

BEST pizza in town, and believe me we have tried them all. Very reasonable prices too. The crust is excellent, you can tell it's made from scratch.

-jsimms37,   08/14/2018Source:

Best pizza in Indy

-Angel Khalil,   08/11/2018Source:

Delicious!

-Sean Sorrell,   08/10/2018Source:

Loved the creative pizza options here

-Dave Shannon,   08/07/2018Source:

Great place! So much food for the money!

-Brett Greenwood,   07/28/2018Source:

Great lunch spot. Love their pizza by the slice combo meals.

-Nick Leonard,   07/27/2018Source:

Food is excellent

-Adam Yovanovich,   07/26/2018Source:

I don't live in Carmel anymore (but used to) and if I ever make my way back to Carmel, I always make a stop here. Been going here since I was younger and is still great pizza

-Aaron McClellan,   07/09/2018Source:

Staff was friendly. Good food.

-DaSmoov54,   07/04/2018Source:

First time ever visiting, it is very reasonable. They have a great selection of pizza's and breadsticks, great tasting!

-Debbie Lobacz,   06/27/2018Source:

Great food, great service! Delicious! Would recommend

-Rob Vas,   06/23/2018Source:

My son played baseball at Grand Park and I saw this place on Yelp. I am a pizza SNOB and love NY Style. This place is the real deal. We had an 18 inch...

-Bill S.,   06/16/2018Source:

great pizzas and nice staff and the only place that has pizza by slice

-Seti N,   06/11/2018Source:

I love the pizza

-Candie Hileman,   06/03/2018Source:

Pizzas good and the area is nice

-dat way,   05/13/2018Source:

Great food and better price!

-Nick Durr,   04/30/2018Source:

The best new York style pizza I had have in Indy!

-Sharon Highbaugh,   04/14/2018Source:

Good to find an east coast Stromboli and not a "sub style" Stromboli. Very good and reasonably priced too.

-Joel Fritchman,   03/25/2018Source:

Best pizza in town, I wish they will be closer

-Esteban Torres,   03/24/2018Source:

Great people, great food. Our 1st time and we are HOOKED. Get The Bella!

-Sean Goble,   03/10/2018Source:

Great place to eat.

-Drew Young,   01/24/2018Source:

I came here after work craving a calzone. The food was delicious, super hot and brought to my table. These guys are great!!

-Devon Pulley,   01/06/2018Source:

Moving here from Philly this is the closest thing we can get to east coast pizza! It’s delicious! Staff is awesome too.

-Kate Mowry,   01/04/2018Source:

Doesn't require reservations. Love the pizza.

-TLC Something - A Journal Journey,   12/30/2017Source:

Best NY style I have found in Indy!

-Thomas Trentanove,   12/23/2017Source:

Great pizza. Friendly Service

-Rosalia Hancock,   12/21/2017Source:

10 out of 10 outstanding

-jetplayer546281,   11/01/2017Source:

We love Bella Pizza! They always help me with bringing the pizza out front because I usually have my toddler in the truck! ���

10/28/2017Source:

I used to work at this location years ago and still crave it. It’s under new management and is doing so much better. If you haven’t been in a year or so I’d definitely come back and try it out again.

10/27/2017Source:

Closest to my favorite Brooklyn pizza place Ninna's order their Sicilian (square pie) and tell them to cook it a little longer than they typically do.

-Jeremy Webner,   09/09/2017Source:

Some of, if not the, best New York style pizza in the city.

-Lenard T,   09/09/2017Source:

Good Experience here - pizza was good, ready on time, and staff was friendly. Well done!

-Ben Browning,   08/30/2017Source:

Best pizza around & everyone is always so nice!! That cutie Erin G is my girl!! She's awesome!!

08/28/2017Source:

Best pizza we have had in a long time!

-MrZamramxc,   08/20/2017Source:

Great pizza, one of the better places in Indy for thin slices.

-Dan Warnock,   08/18/2017Source:

I really like pizza by the slice..the salads suck! Pizza great.

-Steven Rogers,   07/08/2017Source:

Fantastic pizza...the delivery time is a bit long however, it is definately with the wait.

07/02/2017Source: