Bella Rewards
Gain 1 point per $1 spent. As a member of Bella Rewards, you will earn points for each of your purchases. Accumulate points and redeem them to get your favorite foods FREE!
More Information
- When you order on Mondays, every $1 spent earns you 2 points!
- After you have already signed up, each time you call the store from the phone number you used to sign up, loyalty points will automatically be added to your order.
- Loyalty is available for any order type. Carry out, Delivery, or Dine-In.
- Dining in? Simply let the person taking your order know you are a part of the loyalty program, and with the phone number you used to sign up, you’ll be earning towards your next free item!
What People Are Saying
Great pizza!
-Lucas Dargo, 08/10/2019Source:
Delicious inexpensive food
-Eliza Sweeny, 08/09/2019Source:
Great service!
-Morgan Rinehart, 08/04/2019Source:
I love pizza of all kinds. But this reminds me of home in NY. Crispy bottom, balance of cheese and sauce, chewy crust. Even the inside is reminiscent...
-Rich R., 07/31/2019Source:
That pizza is really good . Also they deliver !!!
-Nate Armstrong, 07/30/2019Source:
Reasonable love that it sells by the slice
-Angie Guada, 07/21/2019Source:
The garlic knots looked and tasted delicious. I also had a big slice of pepperoni mushroom on flat crust. Crust of pizzia is stone baked.
-Ken Gardzinski, 07/16/2019Source:
Great food and service
-Michael Riley, 07/08/2019Source:
A great slice! Never disappoints.
-Grant Smith, 06/28/2019Source:
Very good NY style pizza
-Luz I. Gallo, 06/25/2019Source:
Had no clue this place delivered. Love this pizza.
-Joshua Russ, 06/11/2019Source:
Lovee the pizza. Cool lil hs staff. Very helpful and on the ball
-Johnny Rodriguez, 06/04/2019Source:
Great food!!!;
-Danielle Jackson, 05/16/2019Source:
Best NY style in Indy
-Red Baron, 05/09/2019Source:
If you like real Italian pizza this is the place to go. East coast quality
-Jeanette El, 05/04/2019Source:
Friendly staff and the pizza was really good and reasonably priced.
-jenna brockelman, 04/27/2019Source:
The best
-Fred White, 03/30/2019Source:
Super good. Cheap
-Nancy Perry Brough, 03/28/2019Source:
Great food at good price. Will be back soon!
-Mike Sherrill, 03/28/2019Source:
Delicious white pizza! Perfect crust!!
-Julie S., 03/07/2019Source:
Best New York Pizzeria in all of indiana
-Dan Giraldo, 03/06/2019Source:
Bread sticks are soft and nice staff
-Marissa Moschowsky, 03/01/2019Source:
Best NY style pizza in Indy
-Dustin Wasson, 02/23/2019Source:
I did not expect much when I walked in here but I made my husband's night when I returned with take out pizza- he's a New Jersey transplant and this was the closest to NY/NJ style pizza he's had in years.
-Julia Hammond, 02/18/2019Source:
Forgot to order my salad for my luncheon. But the driver came back within a couple of minutes with a half a tray of salad. In the meantime Chase texted me...
-Jennifer S., 02/12/2019Source:
Really good single slices! Perfect for one person.
-julia waggoner, 01/24/2019Source:
Always friendly staff, good food!
-Charity Balow, 01/19/2019Source:
My favorite pizza in Carmel! Expect BIG pieces that are delicious. Always come here for the best pizza.
-Amie Cipolla, 01/17/2019Source:
Good pizza
-Todd Bolding, 01/17/2019Source:
Very tasty New York style pizza. My wife loved it. We will be back
-Larry Laird, 01/14/2019Source:
Great white pizza
-David Frederick, 01/13/2019Source:
Nate Armstrong was very helpful and nice, 10 out of 10 would recommend
-Patrick Lauck, 12/30/2018Source:
Easily the best pizza place in town. Closest thing to East Coast tasting pizza there is an Indiana!
-Ciani Harper, 12/30/2018Source:
They have great food and very friendly staff.
-Stephanie Orr, 12/28/2018Source:
Delicious little chain location. The staff is always fun, and the line moves quickly when they are busy!
-Danielle Wrightsman, 12/20/2018Source:
We are thrilled with Bella's New York Style pizzaria. The BEST !!!
-Ron McKernan, 12/13/2018Source:
GREAT pizza! Nice atmosphere. Awesome hostess!
-Kari Disney, 12/11/2018Source:
Always have great food and service here! A family favorite.
-Courtney King, 12/04/2018Source:
A lot of father and son time at Bella's. It will always have a special place in my heart. Food is great also!
-nodarb llebocs, 11/03/2018Source:
Love those pepperoni breadsticks and the staff is always awesome!
-J. Michelle Sybesma, 10/28/2018Source:
I love the pizzas and the breadsticks 🙂
-Angel Juarez, 10/24/2018Source:
Fantastic service and even better pizza
-Taylor Hansen, 10/21/2018Source:
Love the pizza I am from NJ and its hard to satisfy a Jersey girl of good pizza but this pizza is definitely like NJ pizza!! Just an FYI I cant get you new website to work so I cant order online :(
10/21/2018Source:
Yum!!!
-Aaron Wilson, 09/29/2018Source:
Extremely fast delivery and the guy was funny. Wasn't the best pizza in the world but the star service.
-Kayla Parks, 09/26/2018Source:
Stopped here for lunch. Great atmosphere, fast service, delicious food. Definitely recommended.
-Kaleb Davis, 09/25/2018Source:
I love their pizza
-Sarah Norman, 09/25/2018Source:
Only truely New York style pizza in town.
-c g, 09/12/2018Source:
Good pizza and friendly service. Free Wifi was hidden surprise that let me do some work during a quick lunch.
-aaron hockel, 09/06/2018Source:
(Translated by Google) I liked (Original) Me gusto
-Kgris Gamboa, 09/03/2018Source:
Email Signup
Join our email list today to receive exclusive special offers!