Bella Rewards
Gain 1 point per $1 spent. As a member of Bella Rewards, you will earn points for each of your purchases. Accumulate points and redeem them to get your favorite foods FREE!
More Information
- When you order on Mondays, every $1 spent earns you 2 points!
- After you have already signed up, each time you call the store from the phone number you used to sign up, loyalty points will automatically be added to your order.
- Loyalty is available for any order type. Carry out, Delivery, or Dine-In.
- Dining in? Simply let the person taking your order know you are a part of the loyalty program, and with the phone number you used to sign up, you’ll be earning towards your next free item!
What People Are Saying
I'm in love with this pizza. So hard to find NYC style pizza in Indiana and this place knocks it out of the park. It's definitely the best slice I've had in the Midwest. 🍕
-Ameri Can, 06/12/2021Source:
Always my favorite pizza joint just like I'm back in New York great Always freash!
-Josh Stansberry, 05/27/2021Source:
So yummy. I have ordered whole pizzas both time and they were super hot,fresh, and so yummy!!
-Ashley Nunez, 05/07/2021Source:
Very good pizza and nice outdoor setting to eat and watch people go by. Great counter service too.
-Ron Roberts, 04/10/2021Source:
Always an easy meal with great quality and a friendly staff.
-Nick Mason, 04/06/2021Source:
The best New York style pizza around.
-G G, 03/18/2021Source:
Always can't beat the pizza it's the best
-Scott Budnick, 03/12/2021Source:
Excellent NY style pizza. The staff were really nice and the atmosphere is trendy. I will certainly go back and I heard delivery is free 😊.
-Chris Libera, 03/08/2021Source:
I'm pretty impressed with this place. Good quality and a really good price. Ordered for delivery and the food was hot and delivered within the time quoted....
-Josh R., 03/01/2021Source:
amazing food and employees!
02/27/2021Source:
Love love love the Pepperoni breadsticks!! Not to mention everything else 😁
-Russelleen Wilhite, 02/20/2021Source:
Best pizza in town! Travel from far just to eat here
-Rob Vas, 02/14/2021Source:
Great food ....love there pizza ate it when I was pregnant an I couldn't get enough. My man works here an I love it 😊. Very nice place to eat pizza an family friendly
-Anjela Sizemore, 02/13/2021Source:
Delicious
-Sheena Kulczyk, 02/10/2021Source:
Excellent
-Angie Andrews, 01/31/2021Source:
Great pizza and great atmosphere. Hayley and her team do an amazing job the pizza is SO good. Keep up the good work guys.
-Sam, 01/30/2021Source:
We moved from Jersey and this is the best east coast pizza around! I highly recommend if you are looking for a good NY style pizza!
-Crystal B., 01/27/2021Source:
The absolute best pizza in indiana HANDS DOWN DONT WASTE YOUR TIME ANYWHERE ELSE!!
-rob andrews, 01/23/2021Source:
Being from Long Island, I grew up on NY pizza... Bella is as close as you will get in Indiana.
-Thomas Trentanove, 12/31/2020Source:
One of the closest pizzas to New York style pizza I’ve found in Indiana. Other than pizza de Tito. This place has great food, and friendly staff. Garlic knots are delicious!
12/28/2020Source:
Fabulous Pepperoni Bread Sticks!!! 😋
-Linda Woodburn, 11/14/2020Source:
Best pizza by the slice around!
-Christian Hayden, 10/28/2020Source:
Always one of the best slices of pizza around.
-Mike Henshaw, 10/23/2020Source:
Good quality, good customer service. Fast.
-Travis DuBridge, 10/19/2020Source:
Best New York style pizza in Indiana hands-down. The lasagna is also excellent.
-David G., 10/18/2020Source:
Great prices and delicious food. Their cheese pizza is something I crave constantly.
-Rachel McCaffrey, 09/08/2020Source:
Love the pizza here! Everytime I order delivery, it arrives quickly, fresh and hot. Garlic knots are so good as well. Make sure to try their ranch, its YUM!
-Stephanie Staton, 09/04/2020Source:
Superb, quality, New York style pizza. Authentic NY theme and taste. Staff is excellent and delivery is fast. 10/10 would recommend. EDDIE IS THE MAN! 🤙
-Gary Rolfes, 07/30/2020Source:
if you go into it with the expectation it's like a mall pizza, ny style, it's great! Super fast as well.
-usafradium, 07/19/2020Source:
We order from Bella, all the time, as well as eating in. You can order whole pies or by the slice. If you like the East Coast style of pizza, you won’t be disappointed.
07/15/2020Source:
Delicious
-David Mitchell, 03/17/2020Source:
Excelent pizza!
-Magly Espino, 03/10/2020Source:
a very good pizza eats very well .... nice atmosphere and they speak to you in Spanish and English.
-Ralbert Avila, 02/29/2020Source:
Amazing food and great service!!!
-Jennifer Linville, 02/24/2020Source:
Always great service here! The food has always been just as I remember it back home in New York, awesome!
01/05/2020Source:
My favorite pizza and the best pizza ever! Authentic recipes. Their marinara is amazing.
-Elizabeth Edwards, 11/03/2019Source:
I get lunch here every Sunday! The staff are always wonderful and friendly. Love their cheese breadsticks and the Mars is they make in house for their pizza!
09/23/2018Source:
Nice by the slice joint reminiscent of a New York hole in the wall. Pizza was crisp and thin with a little zip. Personally, I would have liked a little more sauce and cheese, but it wasn’t greasy or disappointing.
08/26/2018Source:
Good pizza for the price! You need to make sure that you get all the pieces cut though we had to use our own pizza cutter to cut it.
07/06/2018Source:
We love Bella Pizza! They always help me with bringing the pizza out front because I usually have my toddler in the truck! ���
10/28/2017Source:
Fantastic pizza...the delivery time is a bit long however, it is definately with the wait.
07/02/2017Source:
Very delicious by-the-slice pizza with gluten-free option! Friendly staff makes it a quick, pleasant spot between shopping or errands.
06/01/2017Source:
Great Calzones great staff of high school kids employed there that are very polite
01/14/2017Source:
I'm from Jersey & I am extremely picky about my pizza. This is by far the closest thing to New York pizza I have found on the area. Fabulous pizza!
10/23/2016Source:
One of the best places to eat in Hamilton Town Center!
12/09/2015Source:
DON HALL ART and SOUTH BEACH MEDIA like Bella Pizzeria
09/22/2015Source:
great tasting ny style pizza! tastes so much better than pizza hut, papa johns!
07/28/2015Source:
Email Signup
Join our email list today to receive exclusive special offers!