Bella Rewards
Gain 1 point per $1 spent. As a member of Bella Rewards, you will earn points for each of your purchases. Accumulate points and redeem them to get your favorite foods FREE!
More Information
- When you order on Mondays, every $1 spent earns you 2 points!
- After you have already signed up, each time you call the store from the phone number you used to sign up, loyalty points will automatically be added to your order.
- Loyalty is available for any order type. Carry out, Delivery, or Dine-In.
- Dining in? Simply let the person taking your order know you are a part of the loyalty program, and with the phone number you used to sign up, you’ll be earning towards your next free item!
What People Are Saying
Great pizza place
-Maria Fernanda Aguirre, 08/16/2022Source:
Always delicious and always great customer service.
-Tianna Penn, 08/12/2022Source:
Great quick meal at reasonable prices
-John E Ridder (Labyrinthguy), 08/10/2022Source:
One of the best pizza places in Noblesville!
-Devin Whitley, 07/29/2022Source:
Closest thing to NY pizza, love it, don't change a thing. Maybe slightly thinner crust as an option.
-Bhupinder Calotia, 07/23/2022Source:
I like it, not the best but definitely is good
-Scott McCord, 07/16/2022Source:
Good Pizza, Good Breadsticks, only been here 2 times so far, and both times were great! Customer service was good, welcomed me in and thanked me for visiting! I'll be back more often!
-Jeffery Biedermann, 07/08/2022Source:
Good
-Jose Perera Nieles, 07/04/2022Source:
Always lightning fast and good variety on the toppings. Try the supreme, it's fantastic
-Flyingferrets5, 07/02/2022Source:
Has the best pizza master making their original NYC STYLE PIZZA LOVE IT
-Daniel Giraldo, 06/03/2022Source:
They have great pizza, friendly employees, and good service.
-Elevator Dude, 05/01/2022Source:
Authentic pizza being made
-Ricky Bullock, 04/30/2022Source:
This pizza is really yummy. So Manny toppings to pick from. The crust is done to perfection, it has a slight mouth watering crunch to it. The Garlic Knots...
-Kim G., 04/29/2022Source:
Love it
-Paula Jo Golday, 04/11/2022Source:
Always amazing
-Nakuma Stone, 04/10/2022Source:
Delicious fresh pizza and kind staff
-Kevin Quay, 03/13/2022Source:
Love Bella pizza. Best NY style pizza around, only if you get it fresh, reheated slices are ok.
-Mojo, 03/12/2022Source:
Best italian food in the Noblesville / Carmel area Pictured is their buffalo chicken pizza & their Panzerotti......
-Daniel K., 02/23/2022Source:
Not to shabby
-Justin Collado, 02/03/2022Source:
Tasty pizza.
-Greg Hess, 01/21/2022Source:
Very good pizza & breadsticks.
-Joo-Yun Kim, 12/11/2021Source:
They have an amazingly friendly staff. The team was more than patient with me picking up my Door Dash order a few minutes after they were close. Great team and great food!
-Constance Bates-Bingham, 12/07/2021Source:
All I can say is wow 🤩 great New York style pizza
-Jason Bryant, 12/06/2021Source:
I had not been to Bella pizza since they closed their location by Keystone. I was passing by Clay Terrace and decided to pick up a takeout order for a tasty...
-Carmen W., 12/03/2021Source:
My go to place for NY style pizza. Close as I can get to foldable slices of my youth!
-Douglas McLean, 11/08/2021Source:
Best Cannolis!!! Great pizza,and breadsticks. Service is excellent.
-Sharon Mason, 10/21/2021Source:
Just moved to fishers and this is hands down the best NY style pizza I’ve had! Great for Sunday football
-Jesse Hall, 09/13/2021Source:
Always yummy.... Just wish one was a little closer to home!
-amy hoopingarner, 09/01/2021Source:
YUM. Just a great place to run and grab a slice! Really friendly crew. :)
-Wendy Cox, 08/22/2021Source:
Their pepperoni bread stick are outstanding. I live in Avon and when I am on the north side it’s a must to stop by Bella’s at the west clay Simon mall to get 3 orders to take home
-Tim Toler (Lotman), 08/10/2021Source:
This is amazing pizza! It's just like I grew up with and definitely brought back memories. The white pizza is divine! Love, love, love!
-Amber Brocken, 08/05/2021Source:
Very good Pizza
-Steve Harrell, 07/09/2021Source:
Always an easy meal with great quality and a friendly staff.
-Nick Mason, 04/06/2021Source:
Always can't beat the pizza it's the best
-Scott Budnick, 03/12/2021Source:
Excellent NY style pizza. The staff were really nice and the atmosphere is trendy. I will certainly go back and I heard delivery is free 😊.
-Chris Libera, 03/08/2021Source:
Great food ....love there pizza ate it when I was pregnant an I couldn't get enough. My man works here an I love it 😊. Very nice place to eat pizza an family friendly
-Anjela Sizemore, 02/13/2021Source:
Great pizza and great atmosphere. Hayley and her team do an amazing job the pizza is SO good. Keep up the good work guys.
-Sam, 01/30/2021Source:
Email Signup
Join our email list today to receive exclusive special offers!