• Home
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • Locations
    • Circle Centre Mall
    • Clay Terrace
    • Hamilton Town Center
  • Rewards
  • Catering
  • Contact Us
  • Pizza
  • •
  • Breadsticks
  • •
  • Calzones & Pizza Rolls
  • •
  • Pasta
  • •
  • Salads
  • •
  • Kid’s Menu
  • •
  • Desserts

Pizza

Whole Pizza

Cheese Pizza XLG: $18.12 LG: $13.76

Toppings: XLG: $2.11   LG: $1.70

Premium Toppings: XLG: $2.75   LG: $2.11

Bella Pizzeria Pizza Sizes

Specialty Pizza

The Bella XLG: $26.61 LG: $19.27

Hot Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, fresh garlic, pepperoni, red onions, mozzarella

Margherita XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Garlic butter sauce, sliced tomatoes, romano, fresh basil leaves, mozzarella

White XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Garlic butter sauce, ricotta, black pepper, romano, mozzarella

Hawaiian XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Ham, pineapple, mozzarella

Veggie Supreme XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Spinach, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mozzarella

Barbecue Chicken XLG: $26.61 LG: $18.12

Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce, roasted chicken, cheddar, mozzarella

Buffalo Chicken XLG: $25.46 LG: $18.12

Frank’s hot sauce, roasted chicken, mozzarella

Meat Lover’s XLG: $26.61 LG: $19.27

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella

Deluxe XLG: $26.61 LG: $19.27

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, mozzarella

Stuffed Pizza

Available only in 18″ XLG

Meat $28.90

Double sausage, double pepperoni, double mozzarella

Gluten-Free Pizza

Available only in 10″

Cheese Pizza $13.99

Each Additional Topping: $1.19

Toppings

  • Pepperoni
  • •
  • Meatballs
  • •
  • Banana Peppers
  • •
  • Black Olives
  • •
  • Black Pepper
  • •
  • Fresh Basil Leaves
  • •
  • Fresh Garlic
  • •
  • Green Olives
  • •
  • Green Peppers
  • •
  • Jalapeños
  • •
  • Mushrooms
  • •
  • Pineapple
  • •
  • Red Onions
  • •
  • Spinach
  • •
  • Tomatoes
  • •
  • White Onions

Premium Toppings

  • Anchovies
  • •
  • Bacon
  • •
  • Ground Beef
  • •
  • Ham
  • •
  • Salami
  • •
  • Sausage
  • •
  • Hot Italian Sausage
  • •
  • Roasted Chicken
  • •
  • Cheddar
  • •
  • Shredded Mozzarella
  • •
  • Feta
  • •
  • Ricotta
  • •
  • Romano
  • •
  • Roasted Red Peppers

Handmade Breadsticks

Breadsticks come in orders of 2 or 4. Garlic Knots come in orders of 5 or 10.

Plain (2) $2.29   (4) $4.59Topped with butter and parsley.
Pepperoni (2) $2.75   (4) $5.50Filled with pepperoni and topped with butter & garlic salt.
Cheezy Weezy (2) $3.21   (4) $6.42Topped with mozzarella, cheddar, and romano.
Garlic Knots (5) $2.98   (10) $5.96Hand-tied bread knots tossed in garlic butter, garlic salt, and parsley.

Dipping Sauces

Every 2 breadsticks (or 5 garlic knots) includes one 2 oz. sauce of your choice.
  • Nacho Cheese
  • •
  • Garlic Butter
  • •
  • Marinara
  • •
  • Ranch

Additional sauce $0.60 each.

Baked Calzones & Pizza Rolls

All calzones and rolls are served with a side of our authentic NY-style marinara sauce.

Calzones

Ham & Cheese $9.04

Ham, ricotta, mozzarella

Combo $9.04

Ham, green peppers, onions, ricotta, mozzarella

Vegetarian $9.04

Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, ricotta, mozzarella

Stromboli $9.04

Ham, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mozzarella

Pizza Rolls

Panzerotti $9.04

Double sausage, double pepperoni, double mozzarella

Spinach Roll $9.04

Fresh spinach, ricotta, mozzarella

Chicken Roll $9.04

Roasted chicken & mozzarella

Pepperoni Roll $9.04

Double pepperoni & mozzarella

Pasta

All of our pasta dishes are served with 3 garlic knots.

Baked Ziti $8.26

Imported penne rigate mixed with creamy ricotta & authentic NY-style marinara, topped with mozzarella

Meat Lasagna $9.40

Homemade meat lasagna layered with cheeses, topped with our authentic NY-style marinara & more cheese

Pasta & Sauce $6.42

Your choice of spaghetti or penne rigate pasta, topped with either our authentic NY-style marinara sauce or butter

Spaghetti & Meatballs $8.49

Imported spaghetti topped with 3 delicious meatballs & our authentic NY-style marinara sauce

Extras

Add Hot Italian Sausage   $2.29
Add Meatballs   $2.29
Add Roasted Chicken   $2.29

Salads

All salads include your choice of dressing.

Tossed Salad Small: $3.90 Large: $6.88

Lettuce, tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, green olives, mozzarella

Side Salad $3.21

Lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella

Greek Salad $7.57

Lettuce, tomatoes, kalamata olives, cucumbers, feta

Antipasto Salad $9.17

Lettuce, tomatoes, ham, salami, black olives, green olives, banana peppers, pepperoni, red onions, mozzarella

Dressings

  • Homemade Italian
  • •
  • Homemade Ranch
  • •
  • Homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette
  • •
  • French
  • •
  • Greek

Extra dressing $0.60 each.

Kid’s Menu

Includes a 16 oz. fountain drink.

Spaghetti & Meatball $5.50

Imported spaghetti topped with 1 meatball and our authentic NY-style marinara sauce

Pasta & Sauce $4.59

Your choice of either spaghetti or penne pasta topped with our authentic NY-style marinara sauce or butter

Desserts

Cheesecake Brownie $2.52

Homemade Cookie $2.06

Cannoli $3.90

View Full PDF Menu

What People Are Saying

Delicious pizzas and bread sticks .

Google

-M M,   05/18/2025Source:

Delicious pizza with fast and friendly service. The only negative is the hooligans that hang out right outside the door of the business.

Google

-Joseph Bledsoe,   05/18/2025Source:

Very good pizza

Google

-Mike,   04/21/2025Source:

DELICIOUS food at an excellent cost! One of my favorite pizza places of all time!

Google

-Whois Jim™,   04/19/2025Source:

I'm from New York City and this place is legit. Other pizza shops don't even come close. The staff very pleasant and friendly. The establishment is very...

Yelp

-Marcus R.,   03/30/2025Source:

It was takeout for boys baseball team and parents between games. VERY well received and appreciated.

Google

-Mike Shaver,   03/19/2025Source:

Best place to stop in for a quick bite.

Google

-Kelli Mac,   02/26/2025Source:

Great place to enjoy lunch while shopping

Google

-Eric Hyrule (Deth65),   02/02/2025Source:

Hands down the best New York style pizza around. It's always fresh and always good. I'm 3 miles away. I can always order, leave immediately and they're getting it out of the oven when I get there.

Google

-Dodd Berry,   01/19/2025Source:

Pizza had a little to much salt for my liking

Google

-Sherry,   12/25/2024Source:

Great little pizza place that has some of the best pizza!

Google

-Nathan Ferguson,   10/05/2024Source:

Bella is our favorite pizza!

Google

-Janet Andriole,   10/03/2024Source:

Great place to get a slice.

Google

-Connor Uzubell,   09/14/2024Source:

As a family from the East Coast, we are always searching for a pizza joint that offers anything that resembles a classic New York slice. Luckily, we found...

Yelp

-Quinn L.,   09/14/2024Source:

It is worth going out of your way. Food is always really good!!!

Google

-J. Maxwell,   09/10/2024Source:

My favorite quality pizza place. Pass by those chain places and spend your money here. It has never disappointed!

Google

-Derek Lynch,   08/29/2024Source:

Delicious thin crust NY-style pizza, breadsticks, salad, free refills on drinks and very friendly, fun employees. Charming NYC decor and plenty of space to sit. The bathroom was also very clean and pleasant.

Google

-Tina Matteson,   08/01/2024Source:

Great pizza.

Google

-Andrew Miller,   07/25/2024Source:

Really good pizza, lots of toppings. Fast delivery directly to the hotel room. Friendly person took my order when over the phone and honored an online deal...

Yelp

-Pete W.,   07/20/2024Source:

Free water would be nice because I needed to fill my cup. I do understand that some could take advantage. The calzone is amazing. No pics because I ate it all

Google

-Esther Monahan,   06/06/2024Source:

This brought me back to my roots in NY! Great little pizzeria with great pizza. We’re just passing through town but if we are ever back, Bella’s is a must.

Google

-Mark hassett,   05/29/2024Source:

If you are looking for authentic by the slice the stuffed is amazing. Been years since I've had it so good

Google

-Adam Cooper,   04/03/2024Source:

I was actually surprised that this pizza joint is good. Ha, we were just walking around and decided to try it since they have individual slices. And you...

Yelp

-Sokly B.,   03/16/2024Source:

This IS the best pizza. Love the NY style thin crust and Louis the owner is the best!!!! From a fellow New Yorker

Google

-Cathy Randall,   03/14/2024Source:

Always great pizza.

Google

-Sam,   03/09/2024Source:

We love the Bella for Two special. The team there is always very friendly and we love the pizza. It’s also great that we can get red peppers as a topping. Yum!

Google

-Andre Harris,   01/14/2024Source:

It’s a hole-in-the-wall New York style pizza joint. Great pizza, great antipasto salad, crispy crust, foldable, no flop good stuff. Meat lovers as a little spice going on from the Italian sausage perfect

Google

-Josh Hill,   12/16/2023Source:

Best white pizza in town.

Google

-David Frederick,   12/10/2023Source:

The closest to NY pizza that we've found in the Indy area, and they have garlic knots...

Google

-Anne Penrosa,   12/09/2023Source:

Ordered catering for 50 pp. was fantastic. Service was great and Manuel delivered it and was on time. Highly recommend.

Google

-Phil Ali,   12/05/2023Source:

Excellent pizza...originally from East Coast and it has been difficult to find good pizza out here...Thank goodness for Bella's and their East Coast style pizza

Google

-Laurie Oshaughnessy,   10/15/2023Source:

The pizza was perfect.

Google

-Tony Salas,   09/18/2023Source:

Good NY pizza, good sticks. My go to for pizza lunch in Carmel. Mmmm cheezy weezy

Google

-Steve W,   09/13/2023Source:

Great place great people and an awesome deal for $9

Google

-aaron russell,   08/29/2023Source:

We moved here from out of Philadelphia and were so discouraged at how lousy pizza in IN is. That is, until we found Bella!! Finally, delicious east coast pizza! We won’t go anywhere else!

Google

-Proverbs 9:10 Ministries,   08/12/2023Source:

Reminds me of NYC pizza! Love it.

Google

-Amy Gallagher,   08/12/2023Source:

Older man was awesome . Dancing while making our food . Awesome service

Google

-Jesse Walker,   07/23/2023Source:

Great pizza in the mall. Fast and workers were friendly too.

Google

-Zac R,   07/01/2023Source:

Flawless. Just flawless.

Google

-Brandon Iott,   04/27/2023Source:

Had a great pizza!!! The sauce was fantastic and crust was just the way i like. Staff was very friendly and helpful. I would eat here everyday.

Google

-Milos Grac,   03/02/2023Source:

Awesome NY Style pizza by the slice. Good price too. Go here!

Google

-David Catalano,   02/08/2023Source:

Delicious pepperoni breadsticks. The crust is perfectly thin, and “floppy” in the best way. Delicious!

Google

-Cameron Workman-Moore,   09/29/2022Source:

Authentic pizza being made

Google

-Ricky Bullock,   04/30/2022Source:

Not to shabby

Google

-Justin Collado,   02/03/2022Source:

Their pepperoni bread stick are outstanding. I live in Avon and when I am on the north side it’s a must to stop by Bella’s at the west clay Simon mall to get 3 orders to take home

Google

-Tim Toler (Lotman),   08/10/2021Source:

Great food ....love there pizza ate it when I was pregnant an I couldn't get enough. My man works here an I love it 😊. Very nice place to eat pizza an family friendly

Google

-Anjela Sizemore,   02/13/2021Source:

Email Signup

Join our email list today to receive exclusive special offers!

Sign Up

Sitemap

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • Locations
  • Rewards
  • Catering
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • © 2018-2025 Bella Pizzeria
    Privacy Policy