- Pizza
- •
- Breadsticks
- •
- Calzones & Pizza Rolls
- •
- Pasta
- •
- Salads
- •
- Kid’s Menu
- •
- Desserts
Pizza
Whole Pizza
Choice of NY style or Sicilian
Cheese Pizza XLG: $15.99 LG: $11.99
Toppings: XLG: $1.99 LG: $1.59
Premium Toppings: XLG: $2.59 LG: $1.99
Specialty Pizza
Gluten-Free Pizza
Available only in 10″
Cheese Pizza $11.99
Each Additional Topping: $1.19
The Big Bella
30″ pizza – you have to tilt it just to fit through the door!
Cheese Pizza $46.99
Each Additional Topping: $4.29
Toppings
- Pepperoni
- •
- Meatballs
- •
- Banana Peppers
- •
- Black Olives
- •
- Black Pepper
- •
- Fresh Basil Leaves
- •
- Fresh Garlic
- •
- Green Olives
- •
- Green Peppers
- •
- Jalapeños
- •
- Mushrooms
- •
- Pineapple
- •
- Red Onions
- •
- Spinach
- •
- Tomatoes
- •
- White Onions
Premium Toppings
- Anchovies
- •
- Bacon
- •
- Ground Beef
- •
- Ham
- •
- Salami
- •
- Sausage
- •
- Hot Italian Sausage
- •
- Roasted Chicken
- •
- Cheddar
- •
- Fresh Ovoline Mozzarella
- •
- Shredded Mozzarella
- •
- Feta
- •
- Ricotta
- •
- Romano
- •
- Roasted Red Peppers
Handmade Breadsticks
Breadsticks come in orders of 2 or 4. Garlic Knots come in orders of 5 or 10.
Plain (2) $1.75 (4) $3.25
Topped with butter and parsley.
Pepperoni (2) $2.25 (4) $3.75
Filled with pepperoni and topped with butter & garlic salt.
Pepperoni & Romano (2) $2.50 (4) $4.50
Filled with pepperoni & mozzarella and topped with romano cheese.
Cheezy Weezy (2) $2.50 (4) $4.50
Topped with mozzarella, cheddar, and romano.
Garlic Knots (5) $2.25 (10) $4.50
Hand-tied bread knots tossed in garlic butter, garlic salt, and parsley.
Dipping Sauces
Every 2 breadsticks (or 5 garlic knots) includes one 2 oz. sauce of your choice.
- Nacho Cheese
- •
- Garlic Butter
- •
- Homemade Marinara
- •
- Homemade Ranch
Additional sauce $0.50 each.
Baked Calzones & Pizza Rolls
All calzones and rolls are served with a side of our homemade marinara sauce.
Calzones
Ham & Cheese $6.99
Ham, ricotta, mozzarella
Combo $6.99
Ham, green peppers, onions, ricotta, mozzarella
Vegetarian $6.99
Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, ricotta, mozzarella
Stromboli $6.99
Ham, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mozzarella
Pizza Rolls
Pasta
All of our pasta dishes are served with 3 garlic knots.
Salads
Dressings
- Homemade Italian
- •
- Homemade Ranch
- •
- Homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette
- •
- French
- •
- Greek
Extra dressing $0.50 each.
Kid’s Menu
Pasta & Sauce $4.29
Your choice of spaghetti or penne rigate with either homemade marinara or butter sauce
Spaghetti & Meatball $4.99
Imported spaghetti topped with 1 meatball and our homemade marinara sauce
Desserts
What People Are Saying
I did not expect much when I walked in here but I made my husband's night when I returned with take out pizza- he's a New Jersey transplant and this was the closest to NY/NJ style pizza he's had in years.
-Julia Hammond, 02/18/2019Source:
Really good single slices! Perfect for one person.
-julia waggoner, 01/24/2019Source:
Always friendly staff, good food!
-Charity Balow, 01/19/2019Source:
Good pizza
-Todd Bolding, 01/17/2019Source:
My favorite pizza in Carmel! Expect BIG pieces that are delicious. Always come here for the best pizza.
-Amie Cipolla, 01/17/2019Source:
Very tasty New York style pizza. My wife loved it. We will be back
-Larry Laird, 01/14/2019Source:
Great white pizza
-David Frederick, 01/13/2019Source:
This is my favorite to go pizza place here in indiana so far. I've been living here for three years and I'm from NYC and this definitely is the closest I've...
-Alison K., 01/06/2019Source:
Nate Armstrong was very helpful and nice, 10 out of 10 would recommend
-Patrick Lauck, 12/30/2018Source:
Easily the best pizza place in town. Closest thing to East Coast tasting pizza there is an Indiana!
-Ciani Harper, 12/30/2018Source:
They have great food and very friendly staff.
-Stephanie Orr, 12/28/2018Source:
Delicious little chain location. The staff is always fun, and the line moves quickly when they are busy!
-Danielle Wrightsman, 12/20/2018Source:
We are thrilled with Bella's New York Style pizzaria. The BEST !!!
-Ron McKernan, 12/13/2018Source:
Indianapolis is seriously lacking in good, NY style pizza. Brozinni's on the southside is excellent, and I've had good luck with Amore in Zionsville. I'm...
-Chris R., 12/13/2018Source:
GREAT pizza! Nice atmosphere. Awesome hostess!
-Kari Disney, 12/11/2018Source:
Always have great food and service here! A family favorite.
-Courtney King, 12/04/2018Source:
A lot of father and son time at Bella's. It will always have a special place in my heart. Food is great also!
-nodarb llebocs, 11/03/2018Source:
Love those pepperoni breadsticks and the staff is always awesome!
-J. Michelle Sybesma, 10/28/2018Source:
I love the pizzas and the breadsticks 🙂
-Angel Juarez, 10/24/2018Source:
Fantastic service and even better pizza
-Taylor Hansen, 10/21/2018Source:
Love the pizza I am from NJ and its hard to satisfy a Jersey girl of good pizza but this pizza is definitely like NJ pizza!! Just an FYI I cant get you new website to work so I cant order online :(
10/21/2018Source:
Perhaps the only thing I miss about living in Charlotte, NC was the influx of New Yorkers that had opened up pizza joints around town. If you understand...
-Justin A., 10/02/2018Source:
Yum!!!
-Aaron Wilson, 09/29/2018Source:
Extremely fast delivery and the guy was funny. Wasn't the best pizza in the world but the star service.
-Kayla Parks, 09/26/2018Source:
I love their pizza
-Sarah Norman, 09/25/2018Source:
Stopped here for lunch. Great atmosphere, fast service, delicious food. Definitely recommended.
-Kaleb Davis, 09/25/2018Source:
Only truely New York style pizza in town.
-c g, 09/12/2018Source:
Good pizza and friendly service. Free Wifi was hidden surprise that let me do some work during a quick lunch.
-aaron hockel, 09/06/2018Source:
Best damn pizza around My son and I have a code word we use around other family members when we want to sneak out for some father / son time
09/04/2018Source:
Me gusto
-Kgris Gamboa, 09/03/2018Source:
BEST pizza in town, and believe me we have tried them all. Very reasonable prices too. The crust is excellent, you can tell it's made from scratch.
-jsimms37, 08/14/2018Source:
Best pizza in Indy
-Angel Khalil, 08/11/2018Source:
Delicious!
-Sean Sorrell, 08/10/2018Source:
Loved the creative pizza options here
-Dave Shannon, 08/07/2018Source:
Great place! So much food for the money!
-Brett Greenwood, 07/28/2018Source:
Great lunch spot. Love their pizza by the slice combo meals.
-Nick Leonard, 07/27/2018Source:
Food is excellent
-Adam Yovanovich, 07/26/2018Source:
I don't live in Carmel anymore (but used to) and if I ever make my way back to Carmel, I always make a stop here. Been going here since I was younger and is still great pizza
-Aaron McClellan, 07/09/2018Source:
Staff was friendly. Good food.
-DaSmoov54, 07/04/2018Source:
First time ever visiting, it is very reasonable. They have a great selection of pizza's and breadsticks, great tasting!
-Debbie Lobacz, 06/27/2018Source:
Great food, great service! Delicious! Would recommend
-Rob Vas, 06/23/2018Source:
great pizzas and nice staff and the only place that has pizza by slice
-Seti N, 06/11/2018Source:
I love the pizza
-Candie Hileman, 06/03/2018Source:
Pizzas good and the area is nice
-dat way, 05/13/2018Source:
Great food and better price!
-Nick Durr, 04/30/2018Source:
The best new York style pizza I had have in Indy!
-Sharon Highbaugh, 04/14/2018Source:
Good to find an east coast Stromboli and not a "sub style" Stromboli. Very good and reasonably priced too.
-Joel Fritchman, 03/25/2018Source:
Best pizza in town, I wish they will be closer
-Esteban Torres, 03/24/2018Source:
Great people, great food. Our 1st time and we are HOOKED. Get The Bella!
-Sean Goble, 03/10/2018Source:
Great place to eat.
-Drew Young, 01/24/2018Source:
Email Signup
Join our email list today to receive exclusive special offers!