• Home
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • Locations
    • Circle Centre Mall
    • Clay Terrace
    • Hamilton Town Center
  • Rewards
  • Catering
  • Contact Us
  • Pizza
  • •
  • Breadsticks
  • •
  • Calzones & Pizza Rolls
  • •
  • Pasta
  • •
  • Salads
  • •
  • Kid’s Menu
  • •
  • Desserts

Pizza

Whole Pizza

Cheese Pizza XLG: $18.12 LG: $13.76

Toppings: XLG: $2.11   LG: $1.70

Premium Toppings: XLG: $2.75   LG: $2.11

Bella Pizzeria Pizza Sizes

Specialty Pizza

The Bella XLG: $26.61 LG: $19.27

Hot Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, fresh garlic, pepperoni, red onions, mozzarella

Margherita XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Garlic butter sauce, sliced tomatoes, romano, fresh basil leaves, mozzarella

White XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Garlic butter sauce, ricotta, black pepper, romano, mozzarella

Hawaiian XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Ham, pineapple, mozzarella

Veggie Supreme XLG: $23.39 LG: $16.97

Spinach, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mozzarella

Barbecue Chicken XLG: $26.61 LG: $18.12

Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce, roasted chicken, cheddar, mozzarella

Buffalo Chicken XLG: $25.46 LG: $18.12

Frank’s hot sauce, roasted chicken, mozzarella

Meat Lover’s XLG: $26.61 LG: $19.27

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella

Deluxe XLG: $26.61 LG: $19.27

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, mozzarella

Stuffed Pizza

Available only in 18″ XLG

Meat $28.90

Double sausage, double pepperoni, double mozzarella

Gluten-Free Pizza

Available only in 10″

Cheese Pizza $13.99

Each Additional Topping: $1.19

Toppings

  • Pepperoni
  • •
  • Meatballs
  • •
  • Banana Peppers
  • •
  • Black Olives
  • •
  • Black Pepper
  • •
  • Fresh Basil Leaves
  • •
  • Fresh Garlic
  • •
  • Green Olives
  • •
  • Green Peppers
  • •
  • Jalapeños
  • •
  • Mushrooms
  • •
  • Pineapple
  • •
  • Red Onions
  • •
  • Spinach
  • •
  • Tomatoes
  • •
  • White Onions

Premium Toppings

  • Anchovies
  • •
  • Bacon
  • •
  • Ground Beef
  • •
  • Ham
  • •
  • Salami
  • •
  • Sausage
  • •
  • Hot Italian Sausage
  • •
  • Roasted Chicken
  • •
  • Cheddar
  • •
  • Shredded Mozzarella
  • •
  • Feta
  • •
  • Ricotta
  • •
  • Romano
  • •
  • Roasted Red Peppers

Handmade Breadsticks

Breadsticks come in orders of 2 or 4. Garlic Knots come in orders of 5 or 10.

Plain (2) $2.29   (4) $4.59Topped with butter and parsley.
Pepperoni (2) $2.75   (4) $5.50Filled with pepperoni and topped with butter & garlic salt.
Cheezy Weezy (2) $3.21   (4) $6.42Topped with mozzarella, cheddar, and romano.
Garlic Knots (5) $2.98   (10) $5.96Hand-tied bread knots tossed in garlic butter, garlic salt, and parsley.

Dipping Sauces

Every 2 breadsticks (or 5 garlic knots) includes one 2 oz. sauce of your choice.
  • Nacho Cheese
  • •
  • Garlic Butter
  • •
  • Marinara
  • •
  • Ranch

Additional sauce $0.60 each.

Baked Calzones & Pizza Rolls

All calzones and rolls are served with a side of our authentic NY-style marinara sauce.

Calzones

Ham & Cheese $9.04

Ham, ricotta, mozzarella

Combo $9.04

Ham, green peppers, onions, ricotta, mozzarella

Vegetarian $9.04

Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, ricotta, mozzarella

Stromboli $9.04

Ham, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mozzarella

Pizza Rolls

Panzerotti $9.04

Double sausage, double pepperoni, double mozzarella

Spinach Roll $9.04

Fresh spinach, ricotta, mozzarella

Chicken Roll $9.04

Roasted chicken & mozzarella

Pepperoni Roll $9.04

Double pepperoni & mozzarella

Pasta

All of our pasta dishes are served with 3 garlic knots.

Baked Ziti $8.26

Imported penne rigate mixed with creamy ricotta & authentic NY-style marinara, topped with mozzarella

Meat Lasagna $9.40

Homemade meat lasagna layered with cheeses, topped with our authentic NY-style marinara & more cheese

Pasta & Sauce $6.42

Your choice of spaghetti or penne rigate pasta, topped with either our authentic NY-style marinara sauce or butter

Spaghetti & Meatballs $8.49

Imported spaghetti topped with 3 delicious meatballs & our authentic NY-style marinara sauce

Extras

Add Hot Italian Sausage   $2.29
Add Meatballs   $2.29
Add Roasted Chicken   $2.29

Salads

All salads include your choice of dressing.

Tossed Salad Small: $3.90 Large: $6.88

Lettuce, tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, green olives, mozzarella

Side Salad $3.21

Lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella

Greek Salad $7.57

Lettuce, tomatoes, kalamata olives, cucumbers, feta

Antipasto Salad $9.17

Lettuce, tomatoes, ham, salami, black olives, green olives, banana peppers, pepperoni, red onions, mozzarella

Dressings

  • Homemade Italian
  • •
  • Homemade Ranch
  • •
  • Homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette
  • •
  • French
  • •
  • Greek

Extra dressing $0.60 each.

Kid’s Menu

Includes a 16 oz. fountain drink.

Spaghetti & Meatball $5.50

Imported spaghetti topped with 1 meatball and our authentic NY-style marinara sauce

Pasta & Sauce $4.59

Your choice of either spaghetti or penne pasta topped with our authentic NY-style marinara sauce or butter

Desserts

Cheesecake Brownie $2.52

Homemade Cookie $2.06

Cannoli $3.90

View Full PDF Menu

What People Are Saying

I am not a fan of pizza... yet I crave bella pizza mouthwatering goodness. The sauce has the perfect tart flavor and it's just so good.

Yelp

-Jenna K.,   06/02/2023Source:

Great pizza

Google

-Otis Woodard,   05/24/2023Source:

Best pizza by far

Google

-Shadeland Wireless,   05/06/2023Source:

Flawless. Just flawless.

Google

-Brandon Iott,   04/27/2023Source:

I can't believe I've never reviewed Bella. The absolute best NY pie maybe even better than home grown Bay ridge. The first bite takes me right back...

Yelp

-Lou S.,   04/21/2023Source:

(Translated by Google) I loved the pizza.. (Original) Amé la pizza..

Google

-Natalia Stefania Behmetiuk,   04/07/2023Source:

Hands down the best New York style pizza around.

Google

-Dodd Berry,   03/06/2023Source:

Had a great pizza!!! The sauce was fantastic and crust was just the way i like. Staff was very friendly and helpful. I would eat here everyday.

Google

-Milos Grac,   03/02/2023Source:

Awesome NY Style pizza by the slice. Good price too. Go here!

Google

-David Catalano,   02/08/2023Source:

Have been meaning to try Bella for a while, and finally did recently. This may be my new favorite pizza place.

Google

-Larry Hymes,   01/11/2023Source:

For those who miss "mall pizza"

Google

-Jordan Hobbs,   01/09/2023Source:

Great place, especially for getting pizza by the slice. The pizza is really good, and staff have always been very friendly. This is one of my favorite lunch spots.

Google

-Rob Tuckfield,   11/17/2022Source:

Best pizza in indiana hands down!

Google

-Richard Stewart,   09/30/2022Source:

Delicious pepperoni breadsticks. The crust is perfectly thin, and “floppy” in the best way. Delicious!

Google

-Cameron Workman-Moore,   09/29/2022Source:

I grew up in NY, this is the closest I've found to being as good as NY pizza in Carmel.

Google

-elisa Savinelli,   09/18/2022Source:

The hands down best pizza by the slice on the north side of Indianapolis

Google

-Doug Mallio,   09/06/2022Source:

Amazing food. I just wish they were open late!!

Google

-Jon Hughs,   08/29/2022Source:

Great pizza place

Google

-Maria Fernanda Aguirre,   08/16/2022Source:

Always delicious and always great customer service.

Google

-Tianna Penn,   08/12/2022Source:

Great quick meal at reasonable prices

Google

-John E Ridder (Labyrinthguy),   08/10/2022Source:

One of the best pizza places in Noblesville!

Google

-Devin Whitley,   07/29/2022Source:

Closest thing to NY pizza, love it, don't change a thing. Maybe slightly thinner crust as an option.

Google

-Bhupinder Calotia,   07/23/2022Source:

I like it, not the best but definitely is good

Google

-Scott McCord,   07/16/2022Source:

Good Pizza, Good Breadsticks, only been here 2 times so far, and both times were great! Customer service was good, welcomed me in and thanked me for visiting! I'll be back more often!

Google

-Jeffery Biedermann,   07/08/2022Source:

Good

Google

-Jose Perera Nieles,   07/04/2022Source:

Always lightning fast and good variety on the toppings. Try the supreme, it's fantastic

Google

-Flyingferrets5,   07/02/2022Source:

Has the best pizza master making their original NYC STYLE PIZZA LOVE IT

Google

-Dan Giraldo,   06/03/2022Source:

They have great pizza, friendly employees, and good service.

Google

-Elevator Dude,   05/01/2022Source:

Authentic pizza being made

Google

-Ricky Bullock,   04/30/2022Source:

Love it

Google

-Paula Jo Golday,   04/11/2022Source:

Always amazing

Google

-Nakuma Stone,   04/10/2022Source:

Delicious fresh pizza and kind staff

Google

-Kevin Quay,   03/13/2022Source:

Love Bella pizza. Best NY style pizza around, only if you get it fresh, reheated slices are ok.

Google

-Mojo,   03/12/2022Source:

Not to shabby

Google

-Justin Collado,   02/03/2022Source:

I had not been to Bella pizza since they closed their location by Keystone. I was passing by Clay Terrace and decided to pick up a takeout order for a tasty...

Yelp

-Carmen W.,   12/03/2021Source:

My go to place for NY style pizza. Close as I can get to foldable slices of my youth!

Google

-Douglas McLean,   11/08/2021Source:

Always yummy.... Just wish one was a little closer to home!

Google

-amy hoopingarner,   09/01/2021Source:

Their pepperoni bread stick are outstanding. I live in Avon and when I am on the north side it’s a must to stop by Bella’s at the west clay Simon mall to get 3 orders to take home

Google

-Tim Toler (Lotman),   08/10/2021Source:

Great food ....love there pizza ate it when I was pregnant an I couldn't get enough. My man works here an I love it 😊. Very nice place to eat pizza an family friendly

Google

-Anjela Sizemore,   02/13/2021Source:

Email Signup

Join our email list today to receive exclusive special offers!

Sign Up

Sitemap

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • Locations
  • Rewards
  • Catering
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • © 2018-2023 Bella Pizzeria
    Privacy Policy