Great NY pie, with excellent service! Price is decent too.

-Live Jay,   01/19/2020Source:

Best New York pizza shop 👌 on this side of the Mississippi

-Puto Face,   01/11/2020Source:

Being an east coast transplant this is as close as it gets for NY style pizza eats! Also one of the few palors where you can get JUST a SLICE! One person doesn't need a whole pizza! Good food!

-Dave Handler,   12/08/2019Source:

Love! Their ranch dressing is amazing to dip pizza in. Pizza is super yummy! If you have any issues the manager is always ready and willing to help. Nice...

-Alisha H.,   12/01/2019Source:

Great pizza,buy it by the slice or whole

-Mark Fouch,   11/24/2019Source:

(Translated by Google) Excellent (Original) Excelente

-Selene Guerrero,   11/22/2019Source:

Excellent every time.

-James Schmidt,   11/10/2019Source:

My favorite pizza and the best pizza ever! Authentic recipes. Their marinara is amazing.

-Elizabeth Edwards,   11/03/2019Source:

Amazing service an great food always a go to

-TJ Treichel,   10/11/2019Source:

I love the New York-style pizza. They have a wonderful variety of breadsticks as well with your choice of cheese or marinara dipping sauce.

-Pastor Fry,   10/08/2019Source:

Because Pepperoni Breadsticks.

-Ryan Russell,   09/28/2019Source:

First time eating here. Were in town for a concert and decided to try it out. Very good!! Would recommend it to others and will come back again when in town!!

-Louisa Schmolinsky,   09/23/2019Source:

Thin crust cheese pizza is a must to have

-Sai Vivek,   08/21/2019Source:

Great pizza!

-Lucas Dargo,   08/10/2019Source:

Delicious inexpensive food

-Eliza Sweeny,   08/09/2019Source:

Great service!

-Morgan Rinehart,   08/04/2019Source:

I love pizza of all kinds. But this reminds me of home in NY. Crispy bottom, balance of cheese and sauce, chewy crust. Even the inside is reminiscent...

-Rich R.,   07/31/2019Source:

That pizza is really good . Also they deliver !!!

-Nate Armstrong,   07/30/2019Source:

Reasonable love that it sells by the slice

-Angie Guada,   07/21/2019Source:

The garlic knots looked and tasted delicious. I also had a big slice of pepperoni mushroom on flat crust. Crust of pizzia is stone baked.

-Ken Gardzinski,   07/16/2019Source:

Great food and service

-Michael Riley,   07/08/2019Source:

A great slice! Never disappoints.

-Grant Smith,   06/28/2019Source:

Very good NY style pizza

-Luz I. Gallo,   06/25/2019Source:

Had no clue this place delivered. Love this pizza.

-Joshua Russ,   06/11/2019Source:

Lovee the pizza. Cool lil hs staff. Very helpful and on the ball

-Johnny Rodriguez,   06/04/2019Source:

Great food!!!;

-Danielle Jackson,   05/16/2019Source:

Best NY style in Indy

-Red Baron,   05/09/2019Source:

If you like real Italian pizza this is the place to go. East coast quality

-Jeanette El,   05/04/2019Source:

Friendly staff and the pizza was really good and reasonably priced.

-jenna brockelman,   04/27/2019Source:

The best

-Fred White,   03/30/2019Source:

Super good. Cheap

-Nancy Perry Brough,   03/28/2019Source:

Great food at good price. Will be back soon!

-Mike Sherrill,   03/28/2019Source:

Delicious white pizza! Perfect crust!!

-Julie S.,   03/07/2019Source:

Best New York Pizzeria in all of indiana

-Dan Giraldo,   03/06/2019Source:

Bread sticks are soft and nice staff

-Marissa Moschowsky,   03/01/2019Source:

Best NY style pizza in Indy

-Dustin Wasson,   02/23/2019Source:

I did not expect much when I walked in here but I made my husband's night when I returned with take out pizza- he's a New Jersey transplant and this was the closest to NY/NJ style pizza he's had in years.

-Julia Hammond,   02/18/2019Source:

Really good single slices! Perfect for one person.

-Julia Waggoner,   01/24/2019Source:

Always friendly staff, good food!

-Charity Balow,   01/19/2019Source:

Good pizza

-Todd Bolding,   01/17/2019Source:

My favorite pizza in Carmel! Expect BIG pieces that are delicious. Always come here for the best pizza.

-Amie Cipolla,   01/17/2019Source:

Very tasty New York style pizza. My wife loved it. We will be back

-Larry Laird,   01/14/2019Source:

Great white pizza

-David Frederick,   01/13/2019Source:

Easily the best pizza place in town. Closest thing to East Coast tasting pizza there is an Indiana!

-Ciani Harper,   12/30/2018Source:

Nate Armstrong was very helpful and nice, 10 out of 10 would recommend

-Patrick Lauck,   12/30/2018Source:

They have great food and very friendly staff.

-Stephanie Orr,   12/28/2018Source:

Delicious little chain location. The staff is always fun, and the line moves quickly when they are busy!

-Danielle Wrightsman,   12/20/2018Source:

We are thrilled with Bella's New York Style pizzaria. The BEST !!!

-Ron McKernan,   12/13/2018Source:

GREAT pizza! Nice atmosphere. Awesome hostess!

-Kari Disney,   12/11/2018Source:

Always have great food and service here! A family favorite.

-Courtney King,   12/04/2018Source: